Benchmade’s New Folding Knife Raises a Controversial Question

Does a survival knife’s blade need to be fixed?

benchmade personal survival knifeBenchmade

Every product is carefully selected by our editors. If you buy from a link, we may earn a commission. Learn more

To fold or not to fold? In the outdoor knife world, answering that question can to some extent define the type of knife at hand, or at least its general category.

If it folds, it can probably pass as an EDC pocket knife — with gonzo exceptions such as the Gerber Double Down. If the blade is fixed, with additional exceptions in the desk/utility knife space — it’s more likely to fall into the bushcraft or survival knife camps. 

The PSK makes the case that one need not pack some over-the-top, full-tang 18-inch Rambo III knife to spend a week in the woods — that an ultra-robust folder will do.

But every once in a while, a folding knife comes along that dares to lay claim to the title of “only one you need when your back’s against the wall.” That appears to be what Oregon-based Benchmade is going for with its latest high-end release, the $400 PSK (“personal survival knife”).

The case for a backcountry folder

Like precious few before it, the PSK makes the case that one need not sheath some over-the-top, full-tang 18-inch Rambo III knife to spend a week in the woods, battling the elements with all the shelter-crafting, game-dressing, fire-building skills in your arsenal — that an ultra-robust folder will do.

We’ve conceded that point ourselves with our best bushcraft and best survival knife guides, both of which include a token folding knife. But we also include a critical caveat in the latter guide: “Folding knives typically don’t make great survival knives — any instance of design complexity is an opportunity for failure. In a folding knife, that’s the pivot. So if you must use a folder for survival, be sure it’s burly.”

The folding knife chosen for that guide, the TOPS Knives Fieldcraft Folder, packs a 4.4-inch drop-point blade made of 1095 carbon steel, a total length of 9.9 inches, micarta handles and a weight of 8.5 ounces.

Still, some hardcore survivalists would insist that a fixed blade is the only way to go, especially with tasks like batoning, where you use a stick or mallet to repeatedly hit the spine of the knife to cut open a thick log and extract dry wood from the inside to make a fire.

benchmade psk carbon fiber
The PSK is also available with carbon fiber and G10 handles for $450.
Benchmade

Is the PSK robust enough?

Which brings us to Benchmade’s latest release, which for its part does pack a lot of impressive features. Chief among them is a MagnaCut steel blade with a Cerakote coating, an AXIS Assist opening and locking mechanism and G10 handles (or, for $50 more, carbon fiber and G10 handles). 

As we’ve noted in the past, MagnaCut is a premium steel boasting a near-peerless combination of toughness, edge retention and corrosion resistance, and the Cerakote only bolsters that last quality, while also keeping the blade clean from task to task. 

Of one thing we are more certain: This is probably the most badass EDC pocket knife you can possibly tote around town.

Meanwhile, G10 handles, steel liners and a super-reliable locking mechanism augur well for this knife’s ability to stab, cut, chop and dig with the best fixed blades around. Lastly, Benchmade left a small patch in the choil un-Cerakoted, enabling you to use a ferro rod to kick up sparks and start a fire.

To be honest, without having tested the knife (yet), our biggest concern about its survival knife bona fides is the blade length. While the overall length is a respectable 8.4 inches, the blade itself is just 3.45 inches. That’s big enough to trust for a lot of tasks, but we wonder how it might fare with the aforementioned batoning, especially considering its weight of just over 5 ounces.

That being said, if anyone can successfully pull off a top-notch yet compact folding survival knife, it’s probably Benchmade. And of one thing we are more certain: This is probably the most badass EDC pocket knife you can possibly tote around town. Just maybe steer clear of airports there, Lone Wolf.

, ,